Personal Banking Team

Theresa Elfring

VP, Senior Manager - Client Experience
NMLS #635966

Theresa is effective in helping to move Croghan forward by providing attention and focus on the customer experience. She is proud to lead and work alongside a team committed to its customers and communities. Theresa sees the value in financial education as a way of providing our youth with the tools and education to lead bright financial futures. She has over 20 years of retail banking experience and is known as a Mom, wife, coach, and volunteer.

Phone: 419-333-4708
Email: telfring@croghan.com

Melissa Walker

VP, Retail Operations Manager
NMLS #579130

Melissa manages branch operations and branch services and works to improve the customer experience. She ensures employees comply with the banking regulations designed to protect customers, employees, and the bank. Melissa oversees all security matters, which range from fraud, adult financial exploitation and even employee and customer safety.

Melissa strives to lead by example, personifying her values of kindness, compassion, empathy, and hard work. She enjoys continuing to expand her knowledge and growth from every experience.

Melissa is a graduate of Fremont St. Joseph Central Catholic High School and a Graduate of the BAI School of Retail Banking at the University of Wisconsin. She is active in her local community, serving as a current member of the Oak Harbor Rotary Club and the Past President of the Port Clinton Rotary Club of Main St Port Clinton.

She resides in Oak Harbor with her husband and enjoys golfing and spending time with her family.

Phone: 419-355-2277
Email: mwalker@croghan.com

Jodi Albright

VP, Regional Manager
NMLS #891757

Being a lifelong resident of Fremont, Jodi is proud to be a community banker and fortunate to be in a position to help others. Jodi has spent her career in retail banking, working closely with the team to ensure an excellent customer experience. She has been instrumental in branch sales and service, retail lending, operations, business development, acquisitions, and security.

Jodi attended Terra State Community College and graduated from the Ohio Bankers League School of Banking and Leadership Sandusky County. She prides herself on being a Croghan Ambassador, being involved in various organizations, and volunteering her time in the community. Jodi is a former President of the Fremont Kiwanis Club and a Chair of the Kiwanis’ All-Inclusive Play Park. She is a Past Chair and Ambassador for the Sandusky County Chamber of Commerce and served on the Downtown Fremont Board of Directors. She is a recipient of the 2014 Sandusky County Chamber of Commerce Clark Ambassador Award.

Jodi enjoys spending time with her husband, daughters, and grandchildren. In her free time, she loves traveling, boating, and camping.

Phone: 419-355-2234
Email: jalbright@croghan.com

Jeanette Eidenour

AVP, Regional Manager
NMLS #630963

Jeanette enjoys working and building relationships in the Fremont area and surrounding communities. She is passionate about helping customers achieve their financial goals, believing each customer has a unique story. By listening and getting to know each customer, she can work to provide a personalized solution, equipping customers with the education and tools they need to achieve financial success. Helping others is one of the most rewarding aspects of her role with Croghan.

Jeanette is a former ambassador for the Sandusky County Chamber, serves on the board of Downtown Fremont, and is a 2018 graduate of Leadership Sandusky County.

Outside of work, Jeanette enjoys spending time with her husband and two children. They enjoy outdoor activities, camping, and working together on their family farm as a family.

Phone: 419-333-4742
Email: jeidenour@croghan.com

Rebecca Estep

AVP, Clyde & Green Springs Area Manager
NMLS #782887

Rebecca is proud to be a community banker, Croghan ambassador, retail lender, and trusted advisor for Clyde, Green Springs, and surrounding communities. The biggest reward of her job is being able to help people. Everyone has their own story and goals, and she gets to help them no matter where they may be on their financial journey. She works hard to help customers achieve their version of financial stability. Rebecca has been working as a banker in the Clyde community for over 20 years and has great pride and love for this community and the people she serves.

Rebecca is a 2008 Sandusky County Chamber of Commerce Clark Ambassador Award winner, a 2016 graduate of Leadership Sandusky County, and a 2017 CASA Dancing with the Stars Champion.

She loves spending time with her son, family, and friends outside of work. Rebecca also loves cooking, listening to music, being outdoors, and thrift shopping.

Phone: 419-547-2759
Email: restep@croghan.com

Maggie Hummel

Port Clinton & Catawba Area Manager
NMLS #2417637

Maggie has over five years of banking experience and believes her strength is being unapologetically herself. She gives her all into what she does and is passionate about learning and growing in whatever capacity she can. Maggie loves to connect on a genuine level with her customers. She strives to live her life in a way that encourages others.  

Maggie graduated high school and went on to receive her PENTA Marketing certificate. She takes pride in being chosen as part of the group that started Croghan Connected and being the Lead Digital Expert, allowing her to train the other Digital Experts on digital banking products. She is a part of Leadership Ottawa County and often volunteers for Croghan events.

Maggie spends most of her time outside the office with her husband and two daughters. They enjoy camping, riding their motorcycle, and spending time with friends. She enjoys cooking, baking, crafting, and cheering on her favorite sports teams.

Phone: 419-732-1186

Email: mhummel@croghan.com

Ashley Hansen

AVP, Oak Harbor, Oregon & Curtice Area Manager
NMLS #1768844

Ashley strives to make it a personal and professional priority as a Croghan Ambassador to focus on the youth in Oak Harbor and surrounding communities. Ashley truly believes in our motto. Her overall goal for the Oak Harbor Market is that her community can identify, without hesitation, that Croghan Colonial Bank has a strong presence and is participating in the community.

Ashley continues to advance within the banking industry, moving from a part-time teller to an Area Manager of her market. She cherishes the fact that she can sit on a few boards in her community as vice president.

Ashley likes to spend time outside work with her husband, two young boys, and her dog. Her family is an outdoor enthusiast, spending their time boating in the summer and snowmobiling in the winter.

Phone: 419-898-8526

Email: ahansen@croghan.com

Elizabeth Lesher

Bellevue & Monroeville Area Manager
NMLS #1909828

Elizabeth began her career at Croghan Colonial Bank in 2015 as a Teller at the Bellevue Office, during which time she was able to help train new Tellers coming into the bank. She prides herself on holding multiple positions within Croghan, allowing her to understand many aspects of the bank.

Elizabeth graduated from Leadership Huron County in December 2023 and believes this program helps with her personal leadership goals and provides valuable ways to strengthen her bond with her community. Elizabeth looks forward to enhancing the client’s experience in Bellevue and Monroeville and serving as the Croghan Ambassador.

Outside of work, she spends time with her husband and two children.

Phone: 419-483-6218
Email: elesher@croghan.com

Lou Anne Sitterly

AVP, Norwalk & Milan Area Manager
NMLS #627366

Lou Anne Sitterly has more than 30 years of experience with Croghan Colonial Bank. Lou Anne has worked in several local communities on her journey to Norwalk. She strives to be an active community member by participating in the local Salvation Army.

Lou Anne’s favorite part of what she does is building personal and business relationships with customers. She loves taking the time with each customer to ensure their needs are fulfilled.

Outside of work, she spends time with her two children and goes out with friends.

Phone: 419-660-6103
Email: lsitterly@croghan.com

Gwen Stallard

AVP, Tiffin Area Manager
NMLS #440053

Gwen Stallard has over 35 years of banking experience in her local communities, and over half of it has been dedicated to helping customers in personal banking. She makes every effort to be an active community member by assisting our customers in the Tiffin Market.

Before coming to Croghan, Gwen attended Hondros College, received her insurance and investments license, and was delighted to incorporate this knowledge into banking.

Gwen also incorporates her vast experience in information technology and project management. With experiences in so many aspects of banking, Gwen is an essential part of Croghan Colonial Bank.

Phone: 419-448-1355
Email: gstallard@croghan.com

Tiffany Wehring

Fremont Area Manager
NMLS #1827643

Tiffany is committed to building meaningful relationships in the Fremont area as the Area Manager with Croghan. With over 25 years of banking experience, she has taken on various roles since joining the team in 2012, including vault teller, assistant manager, and office manager. Tiffany is passionate about helping customers, valuing their trust, and truly enjoys hearing their unique stories. By taking the time to understand their needs, she effectively addresses their concerns and provides tailored solutions.

A proud graduate of Sandusky County Leadership, Tiffany is actively involved in her community and looks forward to meeting new people as she continues to grow professionally in Sandusky County.

When she’s not at work, Tiffany loves spending time with her family and friends, making the most of every moment together.

Phone: 419-355-2204
Email: twehring@croghan.com